Welcome to Costello Properties!

We are a locally owned rental company with residential units in Shadyside, Squirrel Hill, Friendship, Highland Park, Lawrenceville, Bloomfield, East Liberty, South Side, Aspinwall, Point Breeze, Edgewood, Swissvale, Penn Hills, and Braddock.  Our successful business model is to provide the best apartments with the best service. Our tenants enjoy renovated, comfortable spaces with access to a friendly office staff, professional maintenance team, and knowledgeable leasing agents.  Our online tenant portal makes it easy to view your lease, pay your rent, submit maintenance requests, and communicate with management.  

All of our properties are pet friendly for friendly pets with a two pet maximum.  We require up to date vaccination records and licenses for pets before they can enter the property, but we don’t require additional rent or deposits for pets.  There are no breed or weight restrictions.  However, all of our tenants are required to carry renter’s insurance, so your agent will need to be aware of your pets. 

Our places typically rent from summer to summer.  However, we often have apartments available in other seasons when new properties finish renovation or existing tenants move.  We know situations change unexpectedly in life, so we allow or tenants to find approved renters to sublet or take over their leases at any time with no penalties or fees. 

We at Costello Properties treat each tenant like they are family and each home like it is our own. We are proud that many of our units rent by referrals from current or past tenants. If you are in need of a new place to call home, we invite you to become part of our community.  Please go to the "Rentals" tab and look through our available rentals.  If you see any you are interested in send us an inquiry including when you are able to see them and we will do our best to accommodate you.  You can also send an inquiry with the details of what you are looking for.  We look forward to hearing from you!


Search Available Rentals

More search options »

Rental Application

Interested in one of our properties?

Apply online